Memory Card compatibility

One cannot really go by names such as Extreme or Pro or Plus. You have to look for what the card is intended for. Different purposes often have different memory and micro-controllers and software.
Yeah I know, but alot of these cards have same speeds etc Class 10 u3... It would actually be good to do a poll to see what card people are using for their cams and the failure rate and if they are having any issues with different cards.?
 
Yeah I know, but alot of these cards have same speeds etc Class 10 u3... It would actually be good to do a poll to see what card people are using for their cams and the failure rate and if they are having any issues with different cards.?
They don't all have the same speeds owing to microcontrollers / architecture etc which is the confusing bit. Did some testing myself and shared it here and there are variable results.

I think there are some good cards and brands to stick with, and most of the time the consumer will be fine.
 
I use the Sandisk Max Endurance in my A129 Pro without any issues.

Sandisk Max Endurance

In the A229 Pro I am using the VIOFO 256 gig that came with the camera and the Kingston Canvas Go! Plus without any errors.

Kingston Canvas Go! Plus

It is about more than speeds, the memory controller and software are designed for games, photos, 4K, 1080P, constant writes, etc. It is not a cut and dry scenario but is driven by the device that transmits (camera) and the device that receives and writes and reads the data. The memory cards may have the same physical look, other than labels, but the insides can be quite different between the various memory cards.
 
I use the Sandisk Max Endurance in my A129 Pro without any issues.

Sandisk Max Endurance

In the A229 Pro I am using the VIOFO 256 gig that came with the camera and the Kingston Canvas Go! Plus without any errors.

Kingston Canvas Go! Plus

It is about more than speeds, the memory controller and software are designed for games, photos, 4K, 1080P, constant writes, etc. It is not a cut and dry scenario but is driven by the device that transmits (camera) and the device that receives and writes and reads the data. The memory cards may have the same physical look, other than labels, but the insides can be quite different between the various memory cards.
Thanks. Again, just a bit confusing. Do they publish these "memory controller and software" Info?
 
They don't all have the same speeds owing to microcontrollers / architecture etc which is the confusing bit. Did some testing myself and shared it here and there are variable results.

I think there are some good cards and brands to stick with, and most of the time the consumer will be fine.
Do you have a link to the thread? thx M8
 
Do you have a link to the thread? thx M8

There's also some blah blah earlier in the thread I did for Viofo card
 
Thanks. Again, just a bit confusing. Do they publish these "memory controller and software" Info?
Not really from what I've seen apart from the odd well it's X percent more efficient.
 
There is, but it can make for some deep reading. SD Association

Go to the Downloads menu and you can download the whitepapers, specifications, and formatter software for Windows, Mac and Linux.

SD Association Downloads
True for the baseline specs, but doesn't cover the custom solutions that companies may decide to use. E.g. Samsung with their latest Pro Plus line, that's 55% more power efficient with their microcontroller. How the hell anyone would measure that is beyond me haha.

All the specs for SD Express and beyond are a non starter at the moment for MicroSd cards. UHS-II microSD cards are at least out there but beyond them, not sure what the future holds for microSD cards to be honest....
 
Those specs are for full and micro SD cards of all ilks. The Express name on the spec is not the same as card manufacturer marketing using the word Express.

I expect that Samsung and others use some in-house, proprietary software, that may be driven by some degree by who manufactured the micro controller and what type of NAND is on the memory stick. I would guess that
at best, the average consumer will not really know and will have to go by manufacturer recommendations for the dash cam and for the memory card itself.

Where dash cam users run into trouble is they sometimes buy cheap, knock-off memory cards from EBay and others. Some of that memory may say 256gb but actually could be a 32gb that was reprogrammed to say 64 gig. Of course, the
fail rate is usually quite high in those cards. Also, there is no guarantee, the dash cam manufacture, or any device manufacturer is following published specifications.
 
Those specs are for full and micro SD cards of all ilks. The Express name on the spec is not the same as card manufacturer marketing using the word Express.

I expect that Samsung and others use some in-house, proprietary software, that may be driven by some degree by who manufactured the micro controller and what type of NAND is on the memory stick. I would guess that
at best, the average consumer will not really know and will have to go by manufacturer recommendations for the dash cam and for the memory card itself.

Where dash cam users run into trouble is they sometimes buy cheap, knock-off memory cards from EBay and others. Some of that memory may say 256gb but actually could be a 32gb that was reprogrammed to say 64 gig. Of course, the
fail rate is usually quite high in those cards. Also, there is no guarantee, the dash cam manufacture, or an device manufacturer is following published specifications.


Oh definitely not. Sandisk labelling a card Express is not the same as the specification from the SD Association as you say. Was just noting and musing the future of our fond microSD cards.

Still very much the wild west as to exactly how much better one card is than another and what exactly made it that way
 
What I'm curious about is why the Extreme Pro isn't recommended but the regular Extreme is (in the 512GB Section)?

https://www.anandtech.com/show/12002/sandisk-extreme-and-extreme-pro-memory-cards-review/3

Same with Samsung's 512GB Pro Plus and now Pro Ultimate. They both have the same or better standards and specs. You could argue that the microcontrollers are different and all, but in reality, they should be better than what is on the recommended list or just as good.

I regularly use these cards without issue in my A139P. In fact, the Endurance cards are where I had the most issues, ironically. That said, I haven't looked at the underlying flash components but I don't expect them to be worse than what is used in the recommended list.
 
Give it a shot and see, it might be a waste of money
 
Out of curiosity, what happens if i use a 1TB card?
Don't believe they are supported by any manufacturer at the moment, so it is an expensive shot in the dark, if you do try it. I would comfortably stick to the 512GB memory cards recommended by Viofo to be on the safe side, financially and technically.
 
I only know the recommended size of 256 Mb (A139 Pro) .

Quoting: Some of our cameras support 512GB cards, please stick to the same type of card we recommend. While 128/256GB is always a preferable and conservative choice.
 
I only know the recommended size of 256 Mb (A139 Pro) .

Quoting: Some of our cameras support 512GB cards, please stick to the same type of card we recommend. While 128/256GB is always a preferable and conservative choice.
256MB would run out within a minute! Haha
 
I apologize for one faulty transcription. :-(

But just to clarify the issue... how many hours of footage can you fit on it? A 256 Gb card can hold 8-10 hours of footage (parking mode depending on settings about twice as much)? If you need an older archive "to remember" that's a problem. But if you need older records, automatic or manual file locking works.

Nothing against the 512 Gb card, but sometimes there can be problems with it that don't occur with the 256 size. Each to their own. Except that the Sandisk Max Endurance. which is "according to the prices of Sandisk manufacturer models" probably the best quality in 512 capacity does not exist :-( .

I use 2 256 Gb size SDcards and ride a little. I do some archiving (about two months) on my PC at home. My oldest record today is 20231018 with a folder size of 1 TB.
The reason for this archiving isn't because I'm a freak, it's because the police sometimes approach drivers who have driven through a crime scene to provide video footage


1705223703206.png

1705223728663.png
 

Attachments

  • 1705221634202.webp
    1705221634202.webp
    82.7 KB · Views: 221
Last edited:
I apologize for one faulty transcription. :-(

But just to clarify the issue... how many hours of footage can you fit on it? A 256 Gb card can hold 8-10 hours of footage (parking mode depending on settings about twice as much)? If you need an older archive "to remember" that's a problem. But if you need older records, automatic or manual file locking works.

Nothing against the 512 Gb card, but sometimes there can be problems with it that don't occur with the 256 size. Each to their own. Except that the Sandisk Max Endurance. which is "according to the prices of Sandisk manufacturer models" probably the best quality in 512 capacity does not exist :-( .

I use 2 256 Gb size SDcards and ride a little. I do some archiving (about two months) on my PC at home. My oldest record today is 20231018 with a folder size of 1 TB.

The reason for this archiving isn't because I'm a freak, it's because the police sometimes approach drivers who have driven through a crime scene to provide video footage


View attachment 70215
View attachment 70216
Age old question, but as video resolutions increase and storage speeds and all that, then so will memory card / hard drive / SSD storage. So it's just how it is - I try not to think too much about it.

256gb reputable cards are at a cheap enough price now to add onto the cost of a dash cam so it's not such an issue.
 
But just to clarify the issue... how many hours of footage can you fit on it? A 256 Gb card can hold 8-10 hours of footage (parking mode depending on settings about twice as much)?
The recording time of the A229 Pro on a 256GB memory card in three-chamber mode and with a maximum bitrate is 7.5 hours.
In parking mode: “Low bitrate recording”, the recording time of the A229 Pro on a 256GB memory card in three-camera mode is 37.5 hours.
 
Back
Top